Letter to the Professional Engineer PDF Print E-mail
Written by Paul Spare   
Friday, 22 October 2010
Dear Editor,  

The point made by some engineers, that 1.5 kW is too low a value when predicting the number of houses supplied by a wind turbine, should not be dismissed lightly, as the misuse of this statistic hides a multitude of sins.

With an average consumption of 1.5kW, the 20 million UK homes would require an electricity supply of 30,000 MW which is about correct, but that is only part of the picture when evaluating wind power. Since electricity has to be generated the instant that is it needed, the value is meaningless unless the 1.5 kW can be generated to match consumer demand. This is frequently not the case with turbine load factors of circa 20%.

The essence of understanding electricity supply and particularly the damaging consequences of a high renewables penetration, is the diurnal power demand graph and the annual load/demand curve. The latter reveals the duration of power demand through the year.

There is a plateau of 40% that has to be met 8760 hours per annum, but the remaining 60% has to be met by flexible power plants, adjusting continuously to maintain system frequency and power quality.

Wind power is incapable of meeting this requirement. More seriously, wind, wave and solar plants invariably give their minimum output close to periods of maximum demand 6 pm on a freezing night in January and being a variable negative demand in the distribution network are a destabilising factor during periods of unsettled weather.

< Previous   Next >
Downloads

Because of successive changes, much of SONE's literature gives incorrect information about contacting us. The Secretary is Sir Bernard Ingham at:

9 Monahan Avenue
Purley
Surrey
CR8 3BB

Tel:  020 8660 8970
Mobile:  07860 535962
Email:  sec@sone.org.uk


Key SONE downloads:

 


Nuclear questions dispelled.

Questions & Answers
PDF (88k) 14/11/2009 

 

Letters to political parties

Conservative Party
doc (28k) 06/11/2009

Labour Party
doc (28k) 06/11/2009 

Liberal Democrat Party
doc (28k) 06/11/2009

Unions
doc (28k) 06/11/2009 

 

Irish Counterpart

BENE
PDF (400k) 22/12/2012

 

Speaking Notes

Energy Syndrome
doc (111k) 30/12/2010

 

SONE Briefing Notes

Power Cuts in the Making

Energy Price
PDF (88k) 12/02/2012

The Case For Nuclear Power

Energy Facts 2012

PDF (90k) 31/01/2012

Decommissioning in Perspective
PDF (152k) 06/01/2009

Briefing Notes Energy Conservation
PDF (136k) 21/11/2008

Briefing Notes Carbon Cull
PDF (156k) 10/11/2008

Looming Energy Crisis Leaflet
PDF (76k) 22/10/2008

Briefing Notes Energy
PDF (296k) 20/10/2008

Briefing Notes Nuclear
PDF (148k) 20/06/2008

Plutonium in Perspective 
PDF (296k) 01/03/2008

Briefing Notes Hydrogen
PDF (72k) 29/05/2007

Briefing Notes Renewables
PDF (285k) 29/05/2007

Briefing Notes Waste
PDF (352k) 25/04/2007

Briefing Notes
Micro-generation

PDF (56k) 29/06/2006

Briefing Notes Uranium Availability
PDF (44k) 20/01/2006



Click for more downloads